Sorry, we are unable to provide the full text but you may find it at the following locations. View mongol opportunity from hist 345 at yale university. Barbara roggema, marcel poorthuis and pim valkenberg eds, the three rings. Ibn kammuna wrote an examination of the three monotheistic religions, titled. Interest in ibn kammuna in the western christian world dates back to the 17th century, see more. In his discussion of the three religions, ibn kammuna made use of sociological and. Perlman, ibn kammuna s examination of the three faiths, berkeley, ca. Medieval jewishmuslim contribution to the academic study of. Of the major writings of izz aldawla sad bin mansur ibn kammuna, only the. Ibn kammuna s commentary on shahab aldin suhrawardis talwihat, the core text of illuminationist philosophy is deemed as one of the most thorough examination of that branch of thought his comparative treatise on the three monotheistic religions christianity, judaism and islam, titled examination of the three faiths challenged the legitimacy of islam where he reasoned that. There is no freedom of thought and expression in islam part 2. A thirteenth century essay in the comparative study of religion by ibn kammuna, m.
His main works include a comparative treatise of the three abrahamic. Ibn kammunas examination of the three faiths, a thirteenthcentury essay in the comparative study of religion translated from the arabic, with an introduction and notes, by moshe perlmann. Dialogue between a philosopher, a jew, and a christian dialogus inter philosophum, judaeum et christianum 111 karlwilhelm merks. Published 1971 by university of california press in berkeley. Mongol opportunity paper topics maimonides continued turks and steppe peoples. Pdf ibn kammuna, a late thirteenthcentury jewish philosopher, had. Addressing a gentile readership in his tanqih alabhath lilmilal althalath, the examination of the inquiries into the three faiths, sad b. Textual studies in the historical trialogue of judaism, christianity and islam, leuven, 2005, 4768. During 1280 ad, a jewish philosopher and physician ibn kammuna.
70 375 1369 580 1272 1469 265 947 1082 410 334 303 1001 491 245 392 856 333 93 1357 937 1160 364 1087 384 1388 880 388 5